Skip to content
BookCollie

Pricing 6 min read

The Most Profitable Trailer to Rent Out: Dump, Utility, Cargo and Car Hauler, Compared

Dump, utility, enclosed cargo and car hauler trailers compared on price, rental rate, profit, payback and U-Haul's prices, with a free calculator.

BookCollie Team
Four drawn rental trailers parked in a row, a dump trailer, a utility, an enclosed cargo trailer and a car hauler, each with a tag showing how many months it takes to pay for itself: 20, 9, 18 and 11
On this page
  1. The four trailers side by side
  2. What each one costs, and rents for
  3. U-Haul sets the floor
  4. Insurance is the biggest cost on a small trailer
  5. Which trailer for which market
  6. Run your own numbers
  7. Starting out
  8. Taking trailer bookings in BookCollie
  9. Sources

"What's the most profitable trailer to rent out?" Ask it in any trailer owners' group and you'll get four answers, each from someone who owns that trailer.

Here's ours, with the math. A dump trailer makes the most money. A utility trailer pays for itself the fastest. But for your first trailer, buy a car hauler. It costs about a third of a dump trailer, rents for two-thirds as much, pays itself off in under a year, and still pays at U-Haul's price.

The trailer you shouldn't start with: a 6×12 enclosed trailer, unless you can rent it for well over what U-Haul charges.

Below is each one with every cost in, from dealers' and rental businesses' published prices, read on November 18, 2026. BookCollie makes booking software for trailer rental businesses. We'd rather you buy the trailer that pays.

The four trailers side by side

We used the most-rented size of each: a 7×14 14k dump trailer, a 6×12 single-axle utility with a ramp gate, a 7×14 or 7×16 tandem enclosed cargo trailer, and an 18 ft 7k car hauler with a 2 ft dovetail. Each one rents 8 days a month for 10 months, on an 11% loan.

Four trailers, one year, 8 rental days a month

What each makes, how fast it pays for itself, and what happens at U-Haul's price

  • Dump

    7×14, 14k

    New
    $12,500
    Rents for
    $145 a day
    Profit a year
    $6,703
    Paid off in
    1 year 8 months
    Break-even
    3.2 days

    U-Haul doesn't list a dump trailer, so there's no $35 rate to compete with.

  • Utility Fastest payback

    6×12 single axle

    New
    $2,500
    Rents for
    $70 a day
    Profit a year
    $3,361
    Paid off in
    9 months
    Break-even
    3.0 days

    At U-Haul's $34.95: $639 a year, paid off in 3 years.

  • Enclosed cargo

    7×14 or 7×16 tandem

    New
    $7,000
    Rents for
    $95 a day
    Profit a year
    $4,439
    Paid off in
    1 year 6 months
    Break-even
    3.2 days

    At U-Haul's $34.95: −$225 a year, never really pays off.

  • Car hauler

    18 ft + 2 ft dovetail, 7k

    New
    $4,500
    Rents for
    $100 a day
    Profit a year
    $5,055
    Paid off in
    11 months
    Break-even
    2.8 days

    At U-Haul's $69.95: $2,721 a year, paid off in 1 year 6 months.

Each trailer at 8 rental days a month, 10 months a year, on an 11% loan, using the calculator's starting numbers for that kind of trailer. Insurance is one trailer carrying a whole liability policy. U-Haul's rates are its published daily local rates; it lists no dump trailer.

Three things stand out.

Every one breaks even at about 3 rental days a month. Cheaper trailers rent for less, and their costs shrink with them. The number of days you can fill matters more than the trailer you pick.

Profit follows the price of the trailer. The $12,500 dump trailer earns about twice what the $2,500 utility trailer does. It also takes more than twice as long to pay for itself.

U-Haul sets the floor for three of the four. More on that below.

What each one costs, and rents for

Trailer New, published Rents for, published
Dump, 7×14 14k $11,995 to $13,795 (Load Runner Trailers, FL) $145 a day, $870 a week (TJ Trailers, UT)
Utility, 6×12 $2,512 for a Big Tex 35SA (Big Tex Trailer World, TX) $70 a day, $420 a week (TJ Trailers); $95 a day for a 12 ft (ATL Trailer Rental, GA)
Enclosed cargo, 7×14 to 7×16 $6,458 to $7,940 (Big Tex Trailer World; Load Runner) $95 a day, $570 a week (TJ Trailers); $75 a day, $509 a week (Beckley's RVs, MD)
Car hauler, 18 ft 7k $4,175 to $4,833 for a Big Tex 70CH (Big Tex Trailer World) $100 a day, $600 a week (TJ Trailers); $110 a day, $550 a week for a 22 ft (ATL Trailer Rental)

We used TJ Trailers' rates in the math because one Utah business publishes all four. It's one market's prices, not a national average. Rates elsewhere run higher: Affordable Rentals near Colorado Springs charges $95 for a 14 ft utility, $135 for a 14 ft enclosed trailer and $110 for a car hauler.

U-Haul sets the floor

U-Haul publishes its daily local rates (updated February 18, 2026): $34.95 for a 6×12 utility trailer, $34.95 for a 6×12 cargo trailer, $69.95 for its auto transport. It doesn't list a dump trailer.

Your renters have seen those prices. So charge U-Haul's rate and see what's left:

  • Utility at $34.95: about $640 a year. Break-even goes from 3 days a month to 6. Payback: three years.
  • Enclosed cargo at $34.95: it loses money. Break-even: about 9 days a month.
  • Car hauler at $69.95: about $2,700 a year, paid off in a year and a half. Still a business.

That's why the car hauler is our first-trailer pick. Even at U-Haul's price, it works.

It's also why you don't compete with U-Haul on price. You compete on what it won't do:

  • Bigger. The largest cargo trailer on U-Haul's price list is a 6×12. A 7×16 tandem with a ramp door is a different product, for moves, contractors and vendors.
  • Delivered. Drop it in the driveway, pick it up empty.
  • Available. A Saturday trailer you can actually book, online, two weeks ahead.
  • Better kept. A clean deck, working lights, a spare that holds air.

Insurance is the biggest cost on a small trailer

Where a year's rent goes

On a small trailer, insurance is the biggest single cost

  • Dump $11,600 rent · insurance 31% of costs · $6,703 profit

  • Utility $5,600 rent · insurance 45% of costs · $3,361 profit

  • Enclosed cargo $7,600 rent · insurance 35% of costs · $4,439 profit

  • Car hauler $8,000 rent · insurance 41% of costs · $5,055 profit

The calculator's starting numbers for each trailer, at 8 rental days a month, 10 months a year. Insurance is one trailer carrying a whole liability policy, so it weighs most on the cheapest trailers.

On one trailer, you carry a whole business's liability policy. BigRentals' illustrative ranges put general liability at $800 to $1,500 a year for a small fleet, plus $200 to $600 a trailer for inland marine. LogRock's planning illustrations put a low-value utility trailer at $100 to $240 a year and a small cargo trailer at $120 to $420.

So we used about $800 of liability for every trailer, plus its own cover: $1,000 a year for the utility, $1,100 for the cargo trailer, $1,200 for the car hauler. The dump trailer's $1,500 is inside LogRock's $1,000 to $4,000 for a rental-only dump trailer business.

On the utility trailer, that's 45% of everything it costs to run.

Now spread the same liability policy across four trailers. Each one carries $200 of it instead of $800:

  • Utility: paid off in 8 months instead of 9.
  • Car hauler: 10 months instead of 11.
  • Enclosed cargo: 16 months instead of 18.
  • Dump: 19 months instead of 20.

That's the real case for a second trailer. It's not twice the rent. It's the same insurance bill, split.

These are planning figures, not quotes. Get a real one before you buy anything, and tell the agent the trailer is for rent. A personal auto policy almost never covers that.

Which trailer for which market

Dump trailer. Contractors, landscapers, roofers and people clearing out a house. Rents on weekdays and by the week. Highest profit, highest price, highest insurance. Our dump trailer post works through it in detail.

Car hauler. Car buyers, project-car owners, people moving a vehicle across the state, and anyone moving a small tractor. Cheap to buy, simple to maintain, and an open deck has little to damage.

Utility trailer. Mulch, furniture, a riding mower, a dump run. Cheapest way in and fastest payback, but the most renters, the most price shopping and the most competition. Price for the ramp gate, the size or the delivery, not the trailer.

Enclosed cargo trailer. Moves, event vendors, contractors who need lockable storage. Go bigger than U-Haul's 6×12 and rent by the week. Small enclosed trailers at small-trailer prices don't pay.

Run your own numbers

Pick a trailer, then change anything: your price, your rate, your days, your insurance quote. It's also on its own page as the free trailer rental profit calculator.

Your trailer

Start from a typical new trailer, then change anything
$12,500
$145
8 days
10 months
$1,500
$800
$600
11%
65%

Profit a year

$6,703

on $11,600 of rent

Pays for itself in

1 year 8 months

from the cash it brings in

Break-even

3.2

rental days a month, all costs in

Where a year's rent goes

Card fees
$360
Insurance
$1,500
Upkeep
$800
Other costs
$600
Loan interest
$761
Value lost
$875
Profit
$6,703

Profit $6,703 a year on $11,600 of rent. Pays for itself in 1 year 8 months. Break-even at 3.2 rental days a month.

An estimate for one trailer, not a forecast. The loan is the whole price over 5 years; card fees are Stripe's standard US rate of 2.9% + 30¢ per rental day. Income tax, your own time and a truck for delivery aren't included.

The starting numbers are the ones above. Upkeep, other costs and resale value are our estimates; everything else is a published figure. Income tax, your time and a delivery truck aren't included.

Starting out

Our guide to starting a trailer rental business covers picking a niche, paperwork, deposits and your first bookings. The trailer rental agreement template and damage and deposit policy are free.

Taking trailer bookings in BookCollie

Every trailer gets a page on your own booking site with live prices. Renters pick dates, answer the tow compatibility questions if they're towing, sign your agreement and pay, with the deposit held on their card. You set a total for each length of rental, a turnover time after each return, and delivery fees by distance. See how it works for trailer rental businesses.

Sources

All read November 18, 2026. Dealer inventory and rental rates change.

If a price here is out of date, tell us on our contact page.


Want every trailer booked online, not just the Saturday ones? Start a free trial of BookCollie: your own booking site, rates by length, signed agreements and held deposits. See how it works for trailer rental businesses.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most profitable trailer to rent out?

A dump trailer makes the most money: about $6,700 a year at 8 rental days a month, against about $5,000 for a car hauler, $4,400 for an enclosed cargo trailer and $3,400 for a 6×12 utility, with every cost in. For a first trailer we'd buy a car hauler: at about $4,500 new and $100 a day it pays for itself in about 11 months, and it still pays at U-Haul's $69.95 rate. A utility trailer pays off fastest, in about 9 months, but it competes with U-Haul's $34.95.

Is a trailer rental business profitable?

Usually, if each trailer rents enough days. Using published dealer prices and rental rates, a dump, utility, enclosed cargo or car hauler trailer each breaks even at about 3 rental days a month once insurance, upkeep, loan interest, card fees and lost value are counted, and pays for itself in 9 to 20 months at 8 days a month. Below 4 days a month, payback stretches to three to six years. Income tax and your own time come on top.

Is a utility trailer rental business profitable?

A 6×12 utility trailer costs about $2,500 new and pays for itself in about 9 months at $70 a day and 8 days a month. The catch is price: U-Haul rents its 6×12 for $34.95 a day, and at that rate break-even doubles to about 6 days a month and payback takes three years. Utility trailers pay when you charge for something U-Haul doesn't do, like delivery, a ramp gate, a bigger deck or a weekend that's actually available.

Is renting out an enclosed cargo trailer worth it?

At $95 a day, the published rate for a 7×14 tandem in Ogden, Utah, a $7,000 enclosed trailer makes about $4,400 a year at 8 days a month and pays for itself in 18 months. At U-Haul's $34.95 for its 6×12 cargo trailer it loses money. Enclosed trailers pay when they're bigger than U-Haul's, for moves, contractors, events and vendors who need a 7×16 or larger for a week.

How much insurance does a trailer rental business need?

Two kinds, usually: general liability for the business, about $800 to $1,500 a year for a small fleet in BigRentals' illustrative ranges, and cover for each trailer, $200 to $600 a trailer for inland marine in the same guide, or $100 to $420 a year for a utility or small cargo trailer in LogRock's planning illustrations. On one cheap trailer the liability policy is the biggest single cost; spread across four trailers, each one's share drops by three quarters. Get real quotes, since state, use and claims history change the price.

How many rental days a month does a trailer need to break even?

About 3 for each of the four common types at their typical new prices and published rates: 3.2 for a dump trailer, 3.0 for a utility, 3.2 for an enclosed cargo trailer and 2.8 for a car hauler. That counts insurance, upkeep, other costs, loan interest and the value the trailer loses. Charge U-Haul's rates instead and a utility needs about 6 days and a cargo trailer about 9.

Your fleet, booked solid.

Start your 14-day free trial. We'll set it up with you, step by step, and you go live when you're ready.

No credit card · Set up with you · Cancel anytime